December 30, 2006

Carrots and Sticks

I found this interview of Javad Zarif, the Iranian Ambassador to the U.N., of interest, particularly this snippet:

As far as U.S. polices are concerned and the aftermath of the Baker-Hamilton report, what is needed is a change in the approach of the U.S. towards Iran, towards Iraq, and towards the region. What has brought all these miseries to the region is that the U.S. has dealt with the region based on wrong perceptions and a totally erroneous approach. The U.S. must come to realize that other countries have interests, have concerns, have anxieties. The U.S. must deal with these anxieties, concerns and interests, and not be concerned with only its own. Of course any country in any situation will try to maximize its national interest. That’s a given. But, you have to address any situation based on a recognition that the other side also has these similar national interests.

If you deal with the other side as less than a human society, then don’t expect to have multiple outcomes. What I’m saying is that in Western terminology, concepts are used that would infuriate the other sides. Even the terminologies used by the United States in the liberal realist tradition—such as “carrot and stick”—are not meant for humans, but rather for donkeys. In studies of Orientalism, the Eastern part of the world is dealt with as an object rather than as serious, real human societies with longer, older civilizations with concerns and needs that have to be dealt with.

yes indeed. we trivialize their concerns and act imperialistic at every turn. Then we wonder why they resent us.

Posted by: majkia at December 30, 2006 04:53 PM | Permalink to this comment

The appeal to "Orientalism" is unnecessary; the Bush administration deals with Europe and Latin America in precisely the same fashion.

Posted by: Mike Schilling at December 30, 2006 07:30 PM | Permalink to this comment

Our leaders are fools. The government's policies have not only failed in regard to Iran: Cuba, North Korea, and so on, they have strengthened those regimes versus their own citizens. When perchance will we learn form our own experience?

Posted by: Tom Perry at December 30, 2006 11:59 PM | Permalink to this comment